Starbucks’ PSL Returns to Cafes Soon, But These Fall Drinks Might Be Even Better

Pumpkin spice season is arriving early this year, as Starbucks officially brings back its iconic Pumpkin Spice Latte on August 26, 2025. However, while the PSL remains a fall favorite, it's no longer the only seasonal drink turning heads. Across coffee menus nationwide, more creative fall ingredients are being used than ever before.

This season's fall drinks are highly anticipated and prove there's more to your morning routine than the PSL. Whether you're skipping dairy, seeking something spicier, or just plain tired of pumpkin, there are now countless options that stand out from the standard fare. Plus, many of these options are easy to recreate at home, making them just as accessible as they are delicious.

In anticipation of the PSL's release, 247 Tempo brings you 10 fall drinks that arguably outshine the pumpkin spice latte. We've included where to find them, the ingredients you need to make them at home, and what makes each one worth sipping this season. Let's get cozy!

This post was updated on July 22nd, 2025, to reflect additional information.

Silky, sweet Baileys Irish Cream liquor is the key to this spirited hot chocolate. A cup of hot chocolate gains the distinct nutty, creaminess that Baileys is known for. This is an easy recipe to make at home using real Baileys instead of flavored syrup.

Where to Try It: Tim Hortons

• Hot chocolate made with milk
• Bailey's flavored syrup (or liqueur)
• Whipped cream
• Cocoa powder

Hot apple cider has been a staple in cafes for years. On a cold, dreary day, the hot Caramel Apple Spice fall drink is popular with many people across the nation. It's a blend of hot cider sweetened with rich caramel and spices; like apple pie in a glass.

Where to Try It: Starbucks

• Hot apple cider
• Cinnamon syrup
• Whipped cream
• Caramel

Head out shopping and grab a chestnut praline latte to bring with you. The sweet nuttiness of the chestnut praline complements the rich, chocolatey espresso. It's a perfect way to warm up while going from one store to the next.

Where to Try It: Starbucks

• Espresso
• Steamed milk
• Chestnut praline syrup
• Whipped cream
• Praline topping

Oat milk is one of the most popular plant-based milks you can buy. Starbucks is one of the first national coffee shops to provide dairy-free latte options, including their Gingerbread Oatmilk Chai. It tastes just like a hot cup of gingerbread.

Where to Try It: Starbucks

• Chai
• Steamed oat milk
• Gingerbread syrup
• Foam
• Pumpkin spice topping

Many independent coffee shops are offering a sugar cookie latte this fall. Dunkin' has a Holiday Cookie Signature Latte, and you can have it hot or iced. You can also make them at home using Biscoff cookies, available in bulk at Costco.

Where to Try It: Dunkin'

• Espresso
• Steamed milk
• Sugar syrup
• Whipped cream
• Caramel
• Butter cookie crumbles

The sweet and spicy Holiday Spice Latte is a Peet's coffee original. You don't need any sugar syrups to make this drink stand out. Sweeten it to taste, and use pumpkin pie spice for simplicity. It's the perfect hot beverage to have any time of the day.

Where to Try It: Peet's

• Espresso
• Steamed milk
• Cinnamon
• Ginger
• Allspice
• Cloves
• Nutmeg
• Foam

Skip the coffee and head for a floral, milky London Fog. It's similar to a vanilla latte, except you swap the espresso for Earl Grey tea. Many coffee shops, including Tim Hortons, offer this warm, soothing tea. Or pick up some Earl Grey tea and make it yourself at home.

Where to Try It: Tim Hortons

• Earl Grey
• Steamed milk
• Vanilla syrup
• Foam

This is one of the easiest coffee house drinks to make at home, or if you live near a college with a Saxbys, you can order their Milk & Honey Cold Brew. It's delicious and simple. Plus, it's not heavy on added sugar.

Where to Try It: Saxbys

• Cold brew
• Ice
• Milk
• Honey

People love the combination of chocolatey, earthy espresso, pralines, and cream. That's what you get with the Pecan Crunch Oatmilk Latte. If you love pecan-infused coffee blends, this fall drink is going to be right up your alley.

Where to Try It: Starbucks

• Espresso
• Steamed oat milk
• Pecan syrup
• Foam
• Pecan crunch topping

Take a hot chocolate and add spice. Caribou Coffee wows people with a drink that uses real chocolate instead of a powdered mix. Add the heat of chilies and espresso for a warming beverage that's both surprisingly spicy and so decadent.

Where to Try It: Caribou Coffee

• Chocolate pieces
• Steamed milk
• Espresso
• Ancho chili powder
• Chipotle chili powder
• Whipped cream
• Chocolate chips