Make it Yourself! DIY Papa John’s Garlic Dipping Sauce

Like many of our favorite restaurants, Papa John's has a fantastic sauce: Garlic Dipping Sauce. The only bad thing about it is running out, so we came up with a DIY version you can make at home. One thing to note: the original garlic dipping sauce is made with margarine, which is nicer when you want to pull it out of the fridge and spread it on a fresh piece of bread. However, if you prefer a more natural sauce base, butter will work just fine.

Papa John's iconic dipping sauce contains salt, spices, garlic, wheat starch, dried onion, soybean oil, and paprika extract. Surprisingly, Papa John's garlic sauce does not contain actual butter. While some copycat recipes use butter, for a more authentic copycat sauce, it should be made with margarine. The Papa John's website also clarifies that the garlic in the ingredients list is dehydrated, so this famous dipping sauce is made of garlic powder and margarine.

In the late 1980s, Papa John's introduced their signature garlic sauce, which has since become one of the brand's most popular accompaniments to their pizzas and other menu items. Even those who are not big fans of Papa John's pizzas admit their garlic dipping sauce tastes amazing.

Recognizing people's love for their dipping sauce, in 2019, Papa John's turned the garlic flavor into a crust option by baking its Garlic Sauce and Parmesan cheese into the crust. This new specialty pizza also became very popular. Unlike its competitors, Papa John's had not previously offered any flavored crusts.

In 2017, the company played a prank on garlic sauce enthusiasts by announcing on Twitter that it would sell gallon jugs of the sauce for 10 dollars. This idea was met with such enthusiasm that Papa John's actually started offering gallon jugs the following year, although they raised the price to 20 dollars. One TikToker celebrated by making a garlic sauce dipping fountain. However, you do not have to spend that much money. Our copycat recipe rivals the original at a fraction of the cost.

This iconic dipping sauce is made with simple ingredients.

• Margarine — As mentioned earlier, Papa John's garlic sauce is actually made with margarine, not butter. However, do not panic. You can use butter if you prefer. If you do use butter, use unsalted butter because it will melt wonderfully and add more flavor to the sauce.
• Garlic Powder — If you use garlic powder instead of fresh garlic, use it sparingly because it is strong stuff. You can also use roasted garlic, which has a slightly less intense flavor and makes a creamier sauce.
• Salt — Sea salt is a good option for this recipe.
• Spices — Oregano and basil appear in this recipe. For more authenticity, you can also add paprika.

You may also customize this recipe by adding chili flakes for a bit of spiciness or any other spice you enjoy.

To store your leftover Copycat Papa John's Garlic Sauce, follow these steps.

• Allow the garlic sauce to cool completely before transferring it to an airtight container or jar.
• This copycat sauce will last in the refrigerator for up to five days.
• Additionally, this sauce will last in the freezer for up to three months.
• Before serving, stir the sauce thoroughly because the ingredients may have settled.

Pro-tip: If you make a big batch and decide to freeze the extra sauce, you can pour the garlic sauce into ice trays to freeze, which will give you the perfect portions for thawing.

This simple recipe produces a delicious homemade version of Papa John's famous garlic dipping sauce, which is far more affordable than purchasing it directly from the pizza chain.

• 1/2 cup unsalted butter
• 1 teaspoon garlic powder
• 1/4 teaspoon salt (preferably sea salt)
• 1/4 teaspoon dried basil
• 1/4 teaspoon dried oregano

• Cook Time: 5

Our copycat recipe for Papa John's delicious garlic dipping sauce is much cheaper and takes approximately five minutes to prepare. Once you make this copycat sauce, you will want to use it on everything from garlic bread to shrimp to hamburgers. More importantly, you no longer have to worry about sharing or running out of this iconic pizza dipping sauce. You can make enough for everyone.