
Soho A Studio / Shutterstock.com

LizzieMac63 / BY-SA 4.0

NBC Television, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

David Shankbone / BY 3.0

Official Films / BY-SA 4.0

classic film scans / BY 2.0

GustavM / BY-SA 3.0

Ruslan Lytvyn / Shutterstock.com

plumsaplomb / PDM 1.0

NBC Television, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Towpilot / BY-SA 3.0

tanitost / Shutterstock.com

ipopba / Getty Images

Alf Ribeiro / Shutterstock.com

PhilipRomanoPhoto / BY 4.0

w_tanoto (talk) / BY 3.0

New Africa / Shutterstock.com

















16 Disastrous Broadway Musicals That Closed Almost Immediately
Even if a show only lasts a day or two on Broadway, it's still an incredible feat. Not many shows make it to Broadway. In fact, the 2023 - 2024 season saw 71 productions, with a little over half being new ones.
You may be surprised to know that while Broadway shows during that season ran a total of 1,471 playing weeks, not all lasted the entire season. So many shows, during any season, have only lasted a day to a week.
But which ones? To find these Broadway shows, we scoured the internet, reviewing entertainment websites focusing on Broadway musicals and plays. Click through for 16 Broadway musicals that closed almost immediately. While many of these closed before the night was over, they weren't failures. A few had theater runs beforehand or were licensed years later.
"Here's Where I Belong" (1968)
- Opened: March 3, 1968
- Closed: March 3, 1968
- Original Cast: Paul Rogers, Walter McGinn, Ken Kercheval, Scott Jarvis, James Coco, Graciela Daniele, and Heather MacRae
- Music: Robert Waldman
- Lyrics: Alfred Uhry
- Book: Alex Gordon and Terrence McNally
"The Fig Leaves Are Falling" (1969)
- Opened: January 2, 1969
- Closed: January 6, 1969
- Original Cast: Dorothy Loudon, Barry Nelson, Jenny O'Hara, Jay Barney, Louise Quick, David Cassidy, and Frank De Sal
- Music: Albert Hague
- Lyrics: Allan Sherman
- Book: Allan Sherman
"La Strada" (1969)
- Opened: December 14, 1969
- Closed: December 14, 1969
- Original Cast: Bernadette Peters, Stephen Pearlman, Anne Hegira, Larry Kert, Lisa Belleran, Mary Ann Robbins, Susan Goeppinger, and Lucille Patton
- Music: Lionel Bart and Elliot Lawrence
- Lyrics: Lionel Bart and Martin Charnin
- Book: Charles K. Peck, Jr.
"Gentry" (1970)
- Opened: February 14, 1970
- Closed: February 14, 1970
- Original Cast: Robert Shaw, Rita Moreno, Ted Thurston, and Beth Fowler
- Music: Stanley Lebowsky
- Lyrics: Fred Tobias
- Book: Peter Bellwood
Note: Gentry closed during previews and never officially opened on Broadway.
"Home Sweet Homer" (1976)
- Opened: January 4, 1976
- Closed: January 4, 1976
- Original Cast: Yul Brynner, Joan Diener, Russ Thacker, Diana Davila, Darel Glaser, P.J. Mann, Shev Rodgers, and Cecile Santos
- Music: Mitch Leigh
- Lyrics: Charles Burr and Forman Brown
- Book: Roland Kibbee and Albert Marre
"A Broadway Musical" (1978)
- Opened: December 21, 1978
- Closed: December 21, 1978
- Original Cast: Sydney Anderson, Gwen Arment, Nate Barnett, Warren Berlinger, Gwyda DonHowe, Anne Francine, Michael Gallagher, and Jackée Harry
- Music: Charles Strouse
- Lyrics: Lee Adams
- Book: William F. Brown
"The Utter Glory of Morrissey Hall" (1979)
- Opened: May 13, 1979
- Closed: May 13, 1979
- Original Cast: Celeste Holm, Taina Elg, Adrienne Alexander, Willard Beckham, Marilyn Caskey, Patricia Falkenhain, and Laurie Franks
- Music: Clark Gesner
- Lyrics: Clark Gesner
- Book: Clark Gesner and Nagle Jackson
"Onward Victoria" (1980)
- Opened: December 14, 1980
- Closed: December 14, 1980
- Original Cast: Jill Eikenberry, Michael Zaslow, Ted Thurston, Laura Waterbury, Dorothy Holland, Gordon Stanley, and Lenny Wolpe
- Music: Keith Herrmann
- Lyrics: Charlotte Anker and Irene Rosenberg
- Book: Charlotte Anker and Irene Rosenberg
"Bring Back Birdie" (1981)
- Opened: March 5, 1981
- Closed: March 7, 1981
- Original Cast: Donald O'Connor, Chita Rivera, Maria Karnilova, Maurice Hines, Lynnda Ferguson, Marcel Forestieri, Robin Morse, Evan Seplow, and Jeb Brown
- Music: Charles Strouse
- Lyrics: Lee Adams
- Book: Michael Stewart
"Songbook" (1981)
- Opened: May 3, 1981
- Closed: May 3, 1981
- Original Cast: Gary Beach, Jeff Goldblum, Tim Jerome, and Judy Kaye
- Music: Monty Norman
- Lyrics: Monty Norman and Julian More
- Book: Monty Norman and Julian More
"Seven Brides for Seven Brothers" (1982)
- Opened: July 8, 1982
- Closed: July 11, 1982
- Original Cast: Debby Boone, David Carroll, Jeanne Bates, Jeff Calhoun, Cheryl Crandall, and Fred Curt
- Music: Gene de Paul, Al Kasha and Joel Hirschhorn
- Lyrics: Johnny Mercer, Al Kasha and Joel Hirschhorn
- Book: Lawrence Kasha and David Landay
"Dance a Little Closer" (1983)
- Opened: May 11, 1983
- Closed: May 11, 1983
- Original Cast: Len Cariou, Noel Craig, Liz Robertson, George Rose, Don Chastain, Jeff Keller, Brent Barrett, and Alyson Reed
- Music: Charles Strouse
- Lyrics: Alan Jay Lerner
- Book: Alan Jay Lerner
"Raggedy Ann: The Musical Adventure" (1986)
- Opened: October 16, 1986
- Closed: October 19, 1986
- Original Cast: Dick Decareau, Joe Barrett, Richard Ryder, Bob Morrisey, Lisa Rieffel, Ivy Austin, Scott Schafer, Carolyn Marble Valentis, Michelan Sisti, Leo Burmester, Gordon Joseph Weiss, and Gail Kathleen Benedict
- Music: Joe Raposo
- Lyrics: Joe Raposo
- Book: William Gibson
"Rags" (1986)
- Opened: August 21, 1986
- Closed: August 23, 1986
- Original Cast: Teresa Stratas, Josh Blake, Larry Kert, Terrence Mann, Judy Kuhn, Dick Latessa, Lonny Price, Marcia Lewis, and Evelyn Baron
- Music: Charles Strouse
- Lyrics: Stephen Schwartz
- Book: Joseph Stein (with revisions by David Thompson)
"Carrie" (1988)
- Opened: May 12, 1988
- Closed: May 15, 1988
- Original Cast: Linzi Hateley, Betty Buckley, Sally Ann Triplett, Paul Gyngell, Charlotte d'Amboise, Gene Anthony Ray, and Darlene Love
- Music: Michael Gore
- Lyrics: Dean Pitchford
- Book: Lawrence D. Cohen
"Glory Days" (2008)
- Opened: May 6, 2008
- Closed: May 6, 2008
- Original Cast: Steven Booth, Andrew C. Call, Jesse JP Johnson, Adam Halpin, Alex Brightman, and Jeremy Woodard
- Music: Nick Blaemire
- Lyrics: Nick Blaemire
- Book: James Gardiner