After falling in love with an incredible TV show, seeking out additional content with your favorite characters and plot lines is reasonable. In reality, some TV shows should never have been turned into movies. When it comes to the way TV shows are written, the basic format is a lot different than what viewers notice when watching full-fledged movies. Over the years, tons of TV shows have been adapted into movies with overall acceptance from the masses.
That isn’t always the case, though. Other big-name movies inspired by TV shows have proven to be complete disappointments. Who’s at fault when a movie that was inspired by a TV show flops? Is it the production team or the cast lineup? Is it the scriptwriters or the costume designers? There are several factors to consider. The biggest difference between TV shows and movies is that TV shows allow space and time for plots to fully come together across multiple episodes.
If a show snags 10 episodes for one season, the production team has a solid amount of time to tell the story properly. Movies, on the other hand, are much more limited. Typical films run for about an hour and a half before coming to an end. When production teams try to push for longer movies, they’re often met with resistance due to fear of audiences getting bored and restless in their seats. On the topic of TV shows, click here to uncover the most popular all-time TV shows among baby boomers.
To compile this list of TV shows that should have never been turned into movies, 24/7 Tempo consulted several entertainment sources. These include in The Wire, Rotten Tomatoes, ScreenRant, and IMDb.
“The Flintstones” (1994)
IMDb rating: 5/10
Director: Brian Levant
Cast: John Goodman, Rick Moranis, Rosie O’Donnell
“The Flintstones” was a beloved animated TV show that had no business turning into a movie. The fun-loving TV show aired for six season starting in 1960. It focused on a lovable family getting by during the stone ages. Characters like Fred, Pebbles, Betty, and Dino made the cartoon more enjoyable.
In 1994, producers thought it would be a smart idea to turn the animated concept into a movie with live actors. Since the dialogue and jokes incorporated in the live-action movie were too mature for younger audiences, it didn’t match the innocent vibe of the animated show in the slightest.
“Leave It to Beaver” 1997
IMDb rating: 5.2/10
Director: Andy Cadiff
Cast: Christopher McDonald, Janine Turner, Cameron Finley
Starting in 1957, “Leave It to Beaver” was a cherished sitcom that people enjoyed watching with their families. It lasted for six hilarious seasons telling the story of a suburban boy who was always acting up. He’d get into trouble with his family members and neighbors often. Some of the wacky hijinks across episodes included Beaver overflowing a bathtub and Beaver getting suspended from elementary school.
In 1997, a movie of the same name premiered as a way of trying to honor the original show. Since the movie was released decades beyond the show, a new young actor had to be hired for the role of Beaver. Fans who were accustomed to watching Jerry Mathers handle the role didn’t love seeing Cameron Finley try to fill those shoes.
“Bewitched” (2005)
IMDb rating: 4.8/10
Director: Nora Ephron
Cast: Nicole Kidman, Will Ferrell, Shirley MacLaine
anyone who watched the original “Bewitched” show from the late 60s to early 70s can agree that the sitcom was magical. Elizabeth Montgomery took charge in the leading role of Samantha, a powerful witch who fell in love with a mortal man. Since “Bewitched” was such a fun TV show to watch, it ran for eight seasons.
In 2005, producers tried to capitalize off of the show’s magic by releasing the 21st Century movie. Nicole Kidman and Will Ferrell were cast in the leading roles, but they continually seemed to miss the mark in loads of scenes. While it’s obvious that they released “Bewitched” with good intentions, the script was too weak to thoroughly be enjoyed by fans of the original show.
“The Beverly Hillbillies” (1993)
IMDb rating: 5/10
Director: Penelope Spheeris
Cast: Diedrich Bader, Erika Eleniak, Jim Varney
Audiences were once obsessed with “The Beverly Hillbillies” as a TV show. The sitcom premiered in 1962 and lasted for nine captivating seasons. It focused on the Clampett family enjoying luxurious upgrades in life after striking oil on their farm in an unexpected manner.
The rags to riches tale was endearing when viewers first watched it play out across nine seasons. In 1993, producers tried to emulate the TV show’s popularity in a feature film of the same name. Nearly every critical review of the movie was a negative one. Since the movie was chock-full of creative flaws, it was labeled a massive failure.
“Lost in Space” (1998)
IMDb rating: 5.2/10
Director: Stephen Hopkins
Cast: Gary Oldman, William Hurt, Matt LeBlanc
When people think of Matt LeBlanc during the 90s, they often reflect on his time playing Joey Tribbiani on the hit TV show “Friends.” Plenty of fans choose to overlook his decision to star in a 1998 flop of a movie called “Lost in Space.” The space-themed movie was based on a TV show of the same name.
The show originally aired from 1965 until 1968. Back then, shows that honored sci-fi were welcomed with open arms among audiences who were curious to expand their imaginations. By the time LeBlanc and other actors decided to film “Lost in Space” in the late 90s, the concept wasn’t received as openly by audiences.
“Land of the Lost” (2009)
IMDb rating: 5.3/10
Director: Brad Silberling
Cast: Will Ferrell, Danny McBride, Anna Friel
In 2009, a comedy adventure called “Land of the Lost” hit theaters. With a cast lineup including Will Ferrell, Danny McBride, and Anna Friel, it seemed impossible for the movie to take a wrong turn. Unfortunately, it didn’t do well among audiencces. That’s partially because the fans had expectations.
They wanted “Land of the Lost” to maintain the same energy as the TV show from the 70s. For three seasons, “Land of Lost” made waves in the sci-fi community starting in 1974. The show focused on a family in survival mode in the midst of a prehistoric environment. The generalized cheesiness of the 2009 movie didn’t honor the TV show at all.
“The Dukes of Hazzard” (2005)
IMDb rating: 5.1/10
Director: Jay Chandrasekhar
Cast: Seann William Scott, Johnny Knoxville, Jessica Simpson
Plenty of people expected “The Dukes of Hazzard” to be a success when it hit in theaters back in 2005. Based on the original TV show, the movie had every opportunity to woo audiences from start to finish. As a reminder, “The Dukes of Hazzard” TV show premiered in 1979 and lasted for seven seasons.
It focused on a couple of cousins getting into trouble and having fun in their rural community. The producers believed casting Jessica Simpson as Daisy Duke would be enough to impress audiences. That simply wasn’t the case. Ultimately, the movie pulled in a weak 5.1 out of 10 score from IMDb voters.
“The Last Airbender” (2010)
IMDb rating: 4/10
Director: M. Night Shyamalan
Cast: Noah Ringer, Nicola Peltz Beckham, Jackson Rathbone
“The Last Airbender” is a TV show that’s presently revered as one of the best Animes of all time. It premiered in 2005 and lasted for three seasons, telling the story of an eager Airbender named Aang with the capability of controlling water, earth, fire, and air. The show was well-written with high-quality animation to match.
It included the right level of action, adventure, friendship, and romance. Unfortunately, things took a dark turn for fans of “The Last Airbender” when producers decided to make a live-action movie in 2010. The movie was accused of “white washing” the cast by choosing Caucasian actors who didn’t fit the ethnic bill of the characters they were playing.
“Baywatch” (2017)
IMDb rating: 5.5/10
Director: Seth Gordon
Cast: Dwayne Johnson, Zac Efron, Alexandra Daddario
When thinking about the early careers of David Hasselhoff, Jason Momoa, and Pamela Anderson, a show like “Baywatch” often comes to mind. “Baywatch” was a beloved drama that premiered in 1989. It lasted for 11 beloved seasons focused on a group of hard-working lifeguards saving lives at Malibu Beach in Los Angeles. Along with keeping people safe in the ocean, the characters of “Baywatch” dealt with internal struggles of their own as well.
They faced relationship drama, friendship issues, health crises, and more. In 2017, producers thought it would be brilliant to release a “Baywatch” movie in honor of the TV show. They cast Dwayne Johnson, Zac Efron, Priyanka Chopra, and Alexandra Daddario in the leading roles. The A-list cast was an attempt to turn the movie into a success. Still, the storyline fell flat and the movie was forgettable.
“The Mod Squad” (1999)
IMDb rating: 4.3/10
Director: Scott Silver
Cast: Claire Danes, Omar Epps, Giovanni Ribisi
Back in 1968, “The Mod Squad: premiered as an action show for TV lovers to enjoy. It went on for five seasons starring Michael Cole, Pegg, Lipton, and Clarence Williams III. It focused on a group of hippie cops keeping things safe and civil in Southern California. Each episode was full of vibrancy and excitement.
When “The Mod Squad” was released as a 1999 movie, it didn’t come remotely close to matching the TV show’s lovable vibe. The cast lineup was impressive with the likes of Omar Epps, Giovanni, Ribisi, and Claire Danes in the mix. Still, the storyline was too difficult to follow, and the scenes were too boring to get hyped about.
“Starsky & Hutch” (2004)
IMDb rating: 6.1/10
Director: Todd Phillips
Cast: Ben Stiller, Owen Wilson, Snoop Dogg
The 70s was a great era for TV lovers with the premiere of “Starsky & Hutch” in 1975. The action show went on for four seasons, focused on two fictional detectives protecting the citizens of Bay City. One of the detectives was recognized for being street smart, while the other was beloved for being more intellectual.
The premise should have worked well as a movie, but instead, the film version completely flopped in 2004. Audiences described the movie as aimless and overloaded with unnecessarily crude humor. The movie featured Ben Stiller and Owen Wilson in the titular roles, but their star power wasn’t enough to save the day.
“Wild Wild West” (1999)
IMDb rating: 4.9/10
Director: Barry Sonnenfeld
Cast: Will Smith, Kevin Kline, Kenneth Branagh
When a feature film has a big-name actor like Will Smith in the lineup, many viewers assume the movie is going to be a success. That wasn’t the case for “Wild Wild West” in 1999, though. The movie was inspired by a TV show of the same name that premiered in 1965. The series ran for four seasons and focused on two charming Westerners named Artemis Gordon and James West.
One of the men was a handsome gunslinger while the other was a brilliant inventor. In the TV show, the unlikely duo worked well together by bouncing off of each other’s energy. In the movie, most scenes were too unbelievable and corny for audiences to wholeheartedly enjoy. For more coverage on TV shows, click here to be reminded about random TV shows you’ve probably forgotten about.