Many Hollywood stars are forever linked to a single, iconic role. Judy Garland as Dorothy in The Wizard of Oz or Eddie Murphy as Axel Foley in Beverly Hills Cop feel impossible to replace, yet neither actor was the original choice. While these performances seem perfectly matched in hindsight, many beloved characters were nearly played by someone else.
Films and TV shows often hinge on characters audiences instantly connect with, making it hard to imagine anyone else in the role. Still, casting changes happen for many reasons. Actors may pass on a project, leave due to scheduling conflicts or creative differences, or be unable or unwilling to return for sequels or later seasons. In some cases, recasting happens mid-run, sometimes with mixed results.
Replacing an actor can disrupt continuity and chemistry, but it can also lead to unexpected success. Some last-minute changes have resulted in performances that defined entire careers. To identify notable examples, 24/7 Tempo reviewed reporting from entertainment outlets including Vulture, ScreenRant, and The Wrap, along with data from IMDb, to compile a list of famous roles that were recast across film, television, and stage productions.
Rachel Dawes
- Movie: Batman Begins (2005)
- Role originated by: Katie Holmes
- Replacement actor: Maggie Gyllenhaal
Bruce Wayne’s childhood friend and love interest Rachel Dawes in “Batman Begins” was played by Katie Holmes. When the studio began work on the sequel, “The Dark Knight,” Holmes declined to reprise the role, opting instead to work on other projects. The production brought in Maggie Gyllenhaal to play Dawes, who reportedly received Holmes’ blessing before taking on the role.
Aunt Viv
- Movie: The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air (1990-1996)
- Role originated by: Janet Hubert
- Replacement actor: Daphne Reid
This was one of the most notorious and acrimonious splits in TV history. Janet Hubert, who originated the role of Vivian Banks, a.k.a. Aunt Viv, left after the show’s third season. Hubert later said in a memoir that “Fresh Prince” star Will Smith wanted her to be fired, and Smith also alluded to feuding with Hubert after she left the sitcom. Daphne Reid took over as Aunt Viv for the rest of the show’s time on air.
Lt. Col. James ‘Rhodey’ Rhodes / War Machine
- Movie: Iron Man (2008)
- Role originated by: Terrence Howard
- Replacement actor: Don Cheadle
In 2008’s Iron Man, Tony Stark’s friend Lt. Col. James Rhodes was played by Terrence Howard. The film would go on to launch the Avengers franchise and the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe. Ahead of the sequel, it was announced that Don Cheadle would take over as “Rhodey.” Howard later said he was replaced over a contract dispute, alleging he was pressured to take a fraction of the money he previously agreed to. Cheadle has since played Rhodes, and his superhero alter ego War Machine in over half a dozen movies and TV shows.
Harry Potter
- Movie: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child (2016)
- Role originated by: James Snyder
- Replacement actor: Steve Haggard
In early 2022, James Snyder was fired from the lead role in Broadway’s “Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.” A third party investigated misconduct allegations against Snyder from a co-star and determined he should be removed from the show. The role of Harry Potter then went to Steve Haggard, who had been part of the “Cursed Child” production since 2019.
Grindelwald
- Movie: Fantastic Beasts series
- Role originated by: Johnny Depp
- Replacement actor: Mads Mikkelsen
In the first two films in the Harry Potter spinoff Fantastic Beasts series, Johnny Depp starred as the evil wizard Grindelwald. Just after production began on the third movie in 2020, Depp announced that Warner Bros. had asked him to resign from the role, after he lost his libel case against the UK tabloid The Sun. The studio was faced with calls to remove Depp after ex-wife Amber Heard accused him of abuse during their marriage. Depp departed, allowing Mads Mikkelsen to step into the role of Grindelwald for the third film, “Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore.” (Depp was acquitted of all charges and Warner Bros. has since issued an apology.)
Bruce Banner / The Hulk
- Movie: The Incredible Hulk (2008)
- Role originated by: Edward Norton
- Replacement actor: Mark Ruffalo
Although Disney purchased Marvel Studios in 2009, Universal Studios still holds the rights to all characters and can refuse to distribute any stand-alone films. Predating this purchase, “The Incredible Hulk” was produced by Marvel in 2008 and starred Edward Norton as the tragic Bruce Banner and his alter ego. The film was released one month after “Iron Man” but failed to have the same box office success. Marvel alluded to creative differences behind the scenes when they announced Ruffalo would take over the Hulk character going forward alongside the rest of the Avengers.
Professor Dumbledore
- Movie: Harry Potter Series
- Role originated by: Richard Harris
- Replacement actor: Michael Gambon
The role of Albus Dumbledore, mercurial headmaster at Hogwarts in 2001’s “Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone” was originated by veteran actor and two-time Oscar nominee Richard Harris. In 2002, Harris sadly passed away and filmmakers needed another Dumbledore. Michael Gambon stepped into the role for the seven subsequent Potter films.
J. Paul Getty
- Movie: All the Money in the World (2017)
- Role originated by: Kevin Spacey
- Replacement actor: Christopher Plummer
After Kevin Spacey was accused of sexual assault and harassment in 2017, studios scrambled to remove him from ongoing projects. His character was written out of Netflix’s “House of Cards,” but he had also just finished playing billionaire J. Paul Getty in “All the Money in the World,” a biopic about the kidnapping of Getty’s son. Director Ridley Scott opted to reshoot all of Spacey’s scenes with Christopher Plummer, who earned an Oscar nomination for the role.
Victoria
- Movie: Twilight Saga
- Role originated by: Rachelle Lefevre
- Replacement actor: Bryce Dallas Howard
Actress Rachelle Lefevre initially played the role of vampire Victoria in the “Twilight” movie but was replaced after the first two films in the saga with actress Bryce Dallas Howard. The studio issued a statement saying the role was recast because of a scheduling conflict. But Lefevre said in a statement she only had minimal overlap with another project, and that she was “stunned” by the decision not to accommodate her schedule.
George McFly
- Movie: Back to the Future trilogy (1985)
- Role originated by: Crispin Glover
- Replacement actor: Jeffrey Wiseman
Crispin Glover’s exit from the “Back to the Future” films is one of the messiest and most legally complex recasting choices in Hollywood history. Glover portrayed the nerdy George McFly in the first installment but backed out of the sequel over a contract dispute. Rather than just get a new portrayal of George McFly, director Robert Zemeckis opted to use old footage of Glover as well as another actor in prosthetics to look as much like Glover as possible. After the film came out, Glover sued the studio, claiming the look-alike portrayal violated his publicity rights. The case was settled and the Screen Actors Guild adopted new rules against using an actor’s likeness in that way.
Emperor Palpatine
- Movie: Star Wars saga
- Role originated by: Marjorie Eaton/Clive Revill
- Replacement actor: Ian McDiarmid
Sith lord Emperor Palpatine has a small role in “Star Wars: Episode V – The Empire Strikes Back,” appearing briefly as a hologram to give orders to Darth Vader. In the 1980 theatrical release, Palpatine’s body was played by actor Marjorie Eaton, with actor Clive Revill voicing Palpatine’s lines. The Emperor has a much bigger part in “Star Wars: Episode VI – Return of the Jedi,” and the studio wanted one actor for the Palpatine role going forward, so they cast Ian McDiarmid. He has gone on to reprise the role more than half a dozen times for various Star Wars sequels, prequels, and TV shows.
Marianne Peters
- Movie: Army of the Dead (2021)
- Role originated by: Chris D’Elia
- Replacement actor: Tig Notaro
Netflix’s zombie heist film “Army of the Dead” was almost ready to be released when Chris D’Elia, one of its lead actors, was accused of sexual misconduct. Director Zack Snyder and the studio decided to reshoot all of D’Elia’s scenes, but swap in comedian and actor Tig Notaro in his place. The extensive reshoots cost “a few million” dollars according to Snyder, and were further complicated by the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Evelyn Carnahan
- Movie: The Mummy franchise
- Role originated by: Rachel Weisz
- Replacement actor: Maria Bello
The 1999 blockbuster hit, “The Mummy,” gave Rachel Weisz her big break playing Egyptologist Evelyn Carnahan and she reprised the role in the 2001 sequel. She was notably absent from the third installment, “The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor,” where Maria Bello stepped in to play Evelyn. Reports emerged at the time that she left over issues with the script, but Weisz’s representatives blamed scheduling and family conflicts for her departure. However, director Rob Cohen said Weisz left because her character was “too old”.
Clarice Starling
- Movie: The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
- Role originated by: Jodie Foster
- Replacement actor: Julianne Moore
One of the most critically beloved films ever, “The Silence of the Lambs” became just the third film to win the “Big Five” – the Oscar for best picture, directing, actor and actress in a leading role, and screenwriting. But when the studio pushed for a sequel, Jodie Foster and director Jonathan Demme backed out, saying the second script failed to honor the characters established in the first film. Anthony Hopkins returned to reprise the titular role for the sequel, “Hannibal,” but Julianne Moore replaced Foster as FBI agent Clarice Starling.
Laurie Forman
- Movie: That 70s Show (1998-2006)
- Role originated by: Lisa Robin Kelly
- Replacement actor: Christina Moore
Series regular Lisa Robin Kelly played Eric Forman’s older sister Laurie in the first few seasons but when season four premiered, Kelly was noticeably absent. She came back briefly for the fifth season but by season six she was replaced by Christina Moore in a handful of episodes. The character of Laurie was then written out entirely. Kelly later said she was struggling with alcohol abuse at the time and had a falling out with the show’s producers. Sadly, Kelly died in 2013 as a result of a drug overdose.
Gregor “The Mountain” Clegane
- Movie: Game of Thrones (2011-2019)
- Role originated by: Conan Stevens/Ian Whyte
- Replacement actor: Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson
Showrunners kept adjusting certain major roles before “Game of Thrones” aired, but it was the role of the fearsome knight Gregor “The Mountain” Clegane that saw a shift. In season one, the character was played by Conan Stevens but was replaced by Ian Whyte in season two. Because the character’s role expands significantly in season four, someone more fitting to play a character known as “The Mountain” was cast, and in came Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson, a 6’9″ 400-pound Icelandic weightlifter who once claimed the title of World’s Strongest Man.
Meg Griffin
- Movie: Family Guy (1999-present)
- Role originated by: Lacey Chabert
- Replacement actor: Mila Kunis
The original character of Meg Griffin was voiced by actress Lacey Chabert, but Mila Kunis eventually took over and has voiced the character for over two decades and nearly 400 episodes since. The initial split was amicable, as Chabert reportedly was not under contract for the full run of the series and wanted to work on other projects. “Family Guy” creator Seth MacFarlane said there was “no tension” when Chabert departed and Kunis came in to play Meg.
Becky Conner
- Movie: Roseanne (1988-1996, 2018)
- Role originated by: Lecy Goranson
- Replacement actor: Sarah Chalke
The role of Becky Conner is remembered as one of the most confusing recastings in TV history. Lecy Goranson originated the character and played Becky for five seasons. She left the show to focus on her education, which is when actress Sarah Chalke took over the role in seasons six and seven. Goranson’s academic schedule left room for her to return to the role but Chalke was kept on to fill in when Goranson had a scheduling conflict with college. This split-role casting in season eight was confusing, and in season nine Chalke had the role all to herself again. Both actors came back when the show was briefly revived in 2018, but Chalke then played a different character.
Genie
- Movie: Aladdin sequel
- Role originated by: Robin Williams
- Replacement actor: Dan Castellaneta
Robin Williams’ turn as the genie from the animated film “Aladdin” was a classic, free-wheeling comedic performance. But when it came time to make a sequel, Williams refused to return after reportedly feeling Disney did not honor an agreement about not using his voice to sell merchandise. Disney swapped in Dan Castellaneta, a veteran voice actor best known for playing Homer Simpson, as the genie in “Aladdin 2: The Return of Jafar,” as well as several other shows, shorts, and video games. Despite the rift, Williams did return to play Genie in the third Aladdin film.
Jennifer Parker
- Movie: Back to the Future trilogy
- Role originated by: Claudia Wells
- Replacement actor: Elisabeth Shue
The “Back to the Future” franchise changed more than just the character of George McFly between the first and second films. The role of Marty’s girlfriend Jennifer Parker was also switched out. As a result of family obligations, Claudia Wells declined to return to the role, which left it open for Elisabeth Shue to be brought in. She comprised the role for both “Back to the Future Part II” and “Back to the Future Part III.”
The image featured at the top of this post is ©Amy Sussman / Getty Images Entertainment via Getty Images.