The Best Supermarkets in America

Source: gyn9038 / Getty Images

American supermarkets are a wonderment — treasure houses of produce, canned goods, meats and poultry, seafood, dairy products, baked goods, frozen foods, beverages (including alcoholic ones in some states), household necessities, ready-to-eat foods (ranging from sushi to pastrami sandwiches to rotisserie chicken), and more.

According to the Food Marketing Institute, the average U.S. supermarket carries more than 33,000 different items. No wonder such places can be immense. The median size of markets in the country is 41,561 square feet, almost an acre. A location of the Woodman’s chain in Kenosha, Wisconsin, covers almost six times that much area.

Of the roughly 40,000 grocery stores in the U.S., more than 26,000 are classed as conventional supermarkets, meaning that they stock a full line of groceries, meat, and produce — as opposed to natural foods or “gourmet” markets, dollar stores, or warehouse operations that may offer limited selections. These are the most popular grocery stores in every state.

Which of these stores, many of which belong to nationwide or major regional chains, are best? Numerous authorities, ranging from culinary publications to trade journals to the estimable Consumer Reports have published rankings in the recent past. Such factors as quality and variety of products offered, price, cleanliness, and service, among others, are considered.

Based on a number of these sources, 24/7 Tempo has assembled a list of the best supermarkets in America. 

Some markets on the list are small (Stew Leonard’s, on the East Coast, numbers only seven stores) while others have hundreds of locations (the German-owned Aldi discount chain has 2,000-plus). Some are limited to a single state or metro area, while others span the country. 

To identify the best supermarkets in America, 24/7 Tempo reviewed U.S. supermarket rankings  published by Food and Wine, USA Today’s 10 Best, The Daily Meal, Market Force, and Consumer Reports. We created an index based on each grocery store chain’s number of occurrences in these lists and its average rank compared with other supermarkets. Each chain’s number of locations was drawn from company publications.

Walmart, which is often classed as the largest single grocery retailer in America, doesn’t make the cut. Another large-scale chain, the membership-only Costco, does. (Check this list of surprisingly good Costco, Walmart, and Target products.)

Big or small, local or widespread, all of these are the right places to buy food.