Home

 › 

Travel

 › 

The Best Hotels in Mexico and the Caribbean

The Best Hotels in Mexico and the Caribbean

As long as winter in the United States — at least in northern parts of the country — means freezing temperatures, snow, and wearing layers upon layers, Americans will flock to warmer climates.

It’s not surprising therefore that the high tourist season in Mexico (one of the fastest-growing vacations spots in the world) and the Caribbean, which are a relatively short flight away for most Americans, is between December and April. More Americans traveled south of the border in 2018 than to all overseas regions, which include the Caribbean, combined. After Europe, the Caribbeans are the most popular destinations outside United States and North America.

After deciding which country to visit, booking a hotel is often the next step. Everyone wants to get the most bang for their buck, but when money is not the deciding factor, some hotels are better than others.

24/7 Wall St. reviewed Diamond ratings for hotels in Mexico and the Caribbean provided by the American Automobile Association (AAA). To be considered for our list, hotels needed to have a 5-Diamond rating. The insurance and travel firm awards 1 through 5 Diamond ratings only to hotels that upon inspection meet AAA’s criteria for comfort, hospitality, service, and amenities. Top-rated hotels offer highly personalized services and an “impeccable standard of excellence.”

AAA reviews thousands of establishments, and 5-Diamond hotels represent just 0.4% of the nearly 27,000 hotels across North America AAA inspected and approved.

Comparing regions, Playa del Carmen in the Mexican state of Quintana Roo has the most 5 Diamond-rated hotels in Mexico and the Caribbean. Overall, five of the 31 properties on the list the AAA added in 2018.

Hotels aim to achieve the coveted 5 Diamond rating, and each year new hotels make the ranks of the most luxurious hotels and some are demoted. Some have been included for decades. The Ritz-Carlton in Cancún is currently the hotel with the longest tenure on the list – on since 1996. It’s also the only one to have been awarded the status before the turn of the century.

To identify the best hotels in Mexico and Caribbean, 24/7 Wall St. reviewed 5 Diamond ratings provided by AAA. The estimated price for two people in one room for one night — during the high season — was obtained from booking sites such as Hotels.com and Kayak.

Source: Courtesy of The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company

Cayman Islands
> Hotel: The Ritz-Carlton, Grand Cayman
> Location: Seven Mile Beach
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2014
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $2,600

Source: Courtesy of Tortuga Bay Hotel

Dominican Republic
> Hotel: Tortuga Bay Punta Cana Resort & Club
> Location: Punta Cana
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2010
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $945

Source: Courtesy of Spice Island Resort

Grenada
> Hotel: Spice Island Beach Resort
> Location: St. George’s
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2016
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $1,900

Source: Courtesy of The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company

Puerto Rico
> Hotel: Dorado Beach, A Ritz-Carlton Reserve
> Location: Dorado
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2016
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $1,700

Source: Courtesy of Sandy Lane

Barbados
> Hotel: Sandy Lane Hotel
> Location: Holetown (St. James Parish)
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2003
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $750

Source: Courtesy of Kimpton Hotel & Restaurant Group

Cayman Islands
> Hotel: Kimpton Seafire Resort + Spa
> Location: Seven Mile Beach
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2007
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $700

Source: Courtesy of Marriott International, Inc.

Puerto Rico
> Hotel: St. Regis Bahia Beach Puerto Rico
> Location: Rio Grande
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2012
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $2,500

Source: Courtesy of Auberge Resorts

Baja California Sur
> Hotel: Esperanza An Auberge Resort
> Location: Cabo San Lucas
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2017
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $2,000

Source: Courtesy of Montage Hotels and Resorts

Baja California Sur
> Hotel: Montage Los Cabos
> Location: Cabo San Lucas
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2018
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $975

Source: Courtesy of The Resort at Pedregal, Inc.

Baja California Sur
> Hotel: The Resort at Pedregal
> Location: Cabo San Lucas
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2012
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $850

Source: Courtesy of Grand Velas Los Cabos

Baja California Sur
> Hotel: Grand Velas Los Cabos
> Location: San Jose Del Cabo
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2017
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $1,100

Source: Courtesy of Rosewood Hotels & Resorts

Baja California Sur
> Hotel: Las Ventanas al Paraiso, A Rosewood Resort
> Location: San José Del Cabo
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2002
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $900

Source: One&Only Resorts

Baja California Sur
> Hotel: One&Only Palmilla
> Location: San Jose Del Cabo
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2014
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $750

Source: Courtesy of Four Seasons Hotels Limited

Distrito Federal
> Hotel: Four Seasons Hotel Mexico City
> Location: Mexico City
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2016
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $350

Source: Courtesy of Marriott International, Inc.

Distrito Federal
> Hotel: The St. Regis Mexico City
> Location: Mexico City
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2018
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $400

Source: Courtesy of Rosewood Hotels and Resorts

Guanajuato
> Hotel: Rosewood San Miguel de Allende
> Location: San Miguel de Allende
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2018
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $350

Source: Courtesy of TAFER Hotels & Resorts

Jalisco
> Hotel: Hotel Mousai
> Location: Puerto Vallarta
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2015
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $600

Source: Courtesy of Vidanta

Nayarit
> Hotel: Grand Luxxe
> Location: Nuevo Vallarta
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2014
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $500

Source: Courtesy of Velas Resorts

Nayarit
> Hotel: Grand Velas Riviera Nayarit
> Location: Nuevo Vallarta
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2007
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $900

Source: Courtesy of Four Seasons Hotels Limited

Nayarit
> Hotel: Four Seasons Resort Punta Mita
> Location: Punta de Mita
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2001
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $900

Source: Courtesy of Marriott International, Inc.

Nayarit
> Hotel: The St. Regis Punta Mita Resort
> Location: Punta de Mita
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2009
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $800

Source: Courtesy of Palace Resorts

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: Le Blanc Spa Resort
> Location: Cancun
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2010
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $950

Source: Courtesy of Operadora Hotelera Brisas, S.A. de C.V. and Promotora Punta NIZUC, S.A. de C.V.

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: NIZUC Resort & Spa
> Location: Cancun
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2018
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $800

Source: Courtesy of The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: The Ritz-Carlton, Cancún
> Location: Cancún
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 1996
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $650

Source: Courtesy of Banyan Tree Hotels & Resorts

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: Banyan Tree Mayakoba
> Location: Playa del Carmen
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2018
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $1,700

Source: borchee / Getty Images

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: Fairmont Mayakoba
> Location: Playa del Carmen
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2007
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $500

Source: Courtesy of Vidanta

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: Grand Luxxe Riviera Maya
> Location: Playa del Carmen
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2017
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $1,100

Source: olaser / Getty Images

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: Grand Velas Riviera Maya
> Location: Playa del Carmen
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2010
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $900

Source: Andy Lyons / Getty Images

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: Rosewood Mayakoba
> Location: Playa del Carmen
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2009
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $900

Source: Courtesy of AMResorts

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: Secrets Maroma Beach Riviera Cancun
> Location: Playa del Carmen
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2013
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $700

Source: designer491 / Getty Images

Quintana Roo
> Hotel: Zoetry Paraiso de la Bonita Riviera Maya
> Location: Puerto Morelos
> First year 5 Diamond rating was awarded: 2004
> Est. price for 1 guest room: $750

To top