Virtually every major musical artist has released a Christmas album. And even though these performers were famous before they ever cut a record with a holiday theme, some of them, such as Nat King Cole and Bing Crosby, are particularly closely associated with the songs of the season.
To determine the best holiday albums of all time, 24/7 Tempo reviewed data on chart performance from Billboard, current through Nov. 19, 2022, and on certified album sales from the Recording Industry Association of America, current through mid-December. Holiday albums were ranked based on an index combining certified U.S. album sales and an inverse score wherein a week at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 is worth 200 points, a week at No. 2 worth 199 points, and so on, up to a week at No. 200 worth one point. Albums must have also appeared on Billboard’s Top Holiday Albums chart to be considered. Sales data for Elvis Presley’s “Elvis’ Christmas Album” includes certified sales for all reissues of the 1957 album. (These are the most popular Elvis Presley songs.)
Among the top 10 albums on the list, seven were released in the 20th century. Out of the 40 best holiday albums of all time on our list, only six reached No. 1 on the Billboard 200.
Longevity is the hallmark of these LPs. George Winston’s “Dec.” peaked at No. 54 for one week in 1983, but its total time on the Billboard 200 was 178 weeks, en route to selling 3 million records. Two of Trans-Siberian Orchestra’s LPs have each spent more than 60 weeks on the Billboard 200.
On the other hand, some artists have demonstrated that you don’t need a high chart position to mark success. Barbra Streisand’s “A Christmas Album” rose to just No. 108 for two weeks in 1967 – however, it sold 5 million LPs. (See the song of the winter the year you were born.)
Many of the biggest-selling holiday albums are instrumental, and in this category, Mannheim Steamroller and the Trans-Siberian Orchestra dominate. Mannheim Steamroller, which popularized neo-classical electronic New Age music, has four albums on the list whose sale totaled 19 million. Trans-Siberian Orchestra (actually from Tampa, Fla.) is represented by three albums that have sold 7 million copies.
40. Boyz II Men, “Christmas Interpretations”
> Release date: Oct. 5, 1993
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 19 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 15 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
39. Vince Gill, “Let There Be Peace on Earth”
> Release date: Sept. 14, 1993
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 14 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 16 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
24/7 Tempo
38. Kenny Rogers & Dolly Parton, “Once Upon a Christmas”
> Release date: Oct. 2, 1984
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 31 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 38 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
37. Harry Connick, Jr., “When My Heart Finds Christmas”
> Release date: Oct. 22, 1993
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 13 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 10 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 3 million
36. ‘N Sync, “Home for Christmas”
> Release date: Nov. 10, 1998
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 7 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 35 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
35. Kenny G, “Faith: A Holiday Album”
> Release date: Nov. 16, 1999
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 6 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 9 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 3 million
34. Carpenters, “Christmas Portrait”
> Release date: Aug. 24, 1987
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 56 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 61 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 1 million
33. Burl Ives, “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer”
> Release date: March 28, 1995
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 16 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 48 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 500,000
32. Martina McBride, “White Christmas”
> Release date: Sept. 29, 1998
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 64 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 40 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
31. Amy Grant, “Home for Christmas”
> Release date: Oct. 6, 1992
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 2 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 14 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 3 million
30. Trans-Siberian Orchestra, “The Christmas Attic”
> Release date: Oct. 2, 1998
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 60 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 47 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
29. Casting Crowns, “Peace on Earth”
> Release date: Oct. 7, 2008
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 15 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 44 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 1 million
28. Mannheim Steamroller, “Christmas Extraordinaire”
> Release date: Oct. 30, 2001
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 5 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 27 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 3 million
27. Barbra Streisand, “A Christmas Album”
> Release date: Oct. 9, 1967
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 108 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 19 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 5 million
26. Taylor Swift, “The Taylor Swift Holiday Collection (EP)”
> Release date: Dec. 2, 2008
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 20 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 43 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 1 million
25. Chris Tomlin, “Glory in the Highest: Christmas Songs of Worship”
> Release date: Sept. 21, 2009
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 19 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 47 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 500,000
24. Susan Boyle, “The Gift”
> Release date: Nov. 9, 2010
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 1 (for 4 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 33 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 3 million
23. Mannheim Steamroller, “Christmas in the Aire”
> Release date: Sept. 12, 1995
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 3 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 18 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 4 million
22. Pentatonix, “A Pentatonix Christmas”
> Release date: Oct. 21, 2016
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 1 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 44 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 1 million
21. Garth Brooks, “Beyond the Season”
> Release date: Aug. 17, 1992
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 2 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 24 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 3 million
20. Bing Crosby, “White Christmas”
> Release date: Aug. 1, 1977
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 34 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 48 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 4 million
19. Various Artists, “A Very Special Christmas”
> Release date: Oct. 12, 1987
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 20 (for 3 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 34 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 4 million
18. Various Artists, “NOW That’s What I Call Christmas!”
> Release date: Oct. 23, 2001
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 3 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 14 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 6 million
17. Justin Bieber, “Under the Mistletoe”
> Release date: Nov. 1, 2011
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 1 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 59 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
16. Kelly Clarkson, “Wrapped in Red”
> Release date: Oct. 29, 2013
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 3 (for 3 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 56 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 1 million
15. Andrea Bocelli, “My Christmas”
> Release date: Nov. 3, 2009
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 2 (for 5 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 52 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
14. Trans-Siberian Orchestra, “Christmas Eve and Other Stories”
> Release date: Sept. 30, 1996
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 48 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 69 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 3 million
13. Mannheim Steamroller, “A Fresh Aire Christmas”
> Release date: Aug. 15, 1988
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 36 (for 3 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 24 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 6 million
12. Mannheim Steamroller, “Christmas”
> Release date: Sept. 15, 1984
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 29 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 29 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 6 million
11. Trans-Siberian Orchestra, “The Lost Christmas Eve”
> Release date: Oct. 12, 2004
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 26 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 64 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
10. Pentatonix, “That’s Christmas to Me”
> Release date: Oct. 21, 2014
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 2 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 56 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 2 million
9. Kenny G, “Miracles: The Holiday Album”
> Release date: Nov. 1, 1994
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 1 (for 3 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 17 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 8 million
8. Celine Dion, “These Are Special Times”
> Release date: Nov. 3, 1998
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 2 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 78 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 5 million
7. Nat King Cole, “The Christmas Song”
> Release date: Sept. 1, 1963
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 6 (for 2 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 65 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 6 million
6. George Winston, “Dec.”
> Release date: Aug. 19, 1983
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 54 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 178 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 3 million
5. Vince Guaraldi Trio, “A Charlie Brown Christmas (Soundtrack)”
> Release date: Sept. 18, 1978
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 6 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 99 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 4 million
4. Josh Groban, “Noël”
> Release date: Oct. 9, 2007
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 1 (for 5 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 103 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 6 million
3. Mariah Carey, “Merry Christmas”
> Release date: Oct. 28, 1994
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 3 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 108 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 8 million
2. Michael Buble, “Christmas”
> Release date: Oct. 14, 2011
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 1 (for 5 weeks)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 100 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 6 million
1. Elvis Presley, “Elvis’ Christmas Album”
> Release date: Oct. 15, 1957
> Peak position on Billboard 200: No. 25 (for 1 week)
> Total time on Billboard 200: 75 weeks
> Certified U.S. album sales: 17 million
Sponsored: Find a Qualified Financial Advisor
Finding a qualified financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with up to 3 fiduciary financial advisors in your area in 5 minutes. Each advisor has been vetted by SmartAsset and is held to a fiduciary standard to act in your best interests. If you’re ready to be matched with local advisors that can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Tempo Editorial team.
